Is Dairy Farming Cruel?
Warning: This article contains graphic descriptions and images from undercover investigations into the dairy industry. Viewer discretion is advised.
The year 2025 is still fresh, yet it’s already become notorious for exposing the deep and painful wounds hidden behind the idyllic imagery of dairy farming. Two groundbreaking undercover investigations, one in the United States and another in the United Kingdom, have revealed shocking, unimaginable violence against dairy cows—including heartbreaking cruelty toward vulnerable newborn calves and mothers in labor.
Animal advocacy organizations have responded swiftly, demanding legal accountability and raising public awareness. Yet, as predictably as ever, the dairy industry has retaliated with familiar rhetoric: blaming these atrocities on isolated “bad apples” and rogue employees. But is cruelty in dairy farming truly limited to these isolated instances, or is it something far more systemic and widespread?
Just a Few Bad Apples?
In February 2025, Animal Recovery Mission (ARM) revealed shocking cruelty at Butterfield Dairy and Rainbow Valley Dairy near Phoenix, Arizona—both key suppliers for Coca-Cola’s Fairlife milk. Despite Fairlife's claims of humane sourcing, investigators documented calves violently separated from mothers, beaten, neglected, and left to die from untreated injuries or extreme heat. Pregnant cows faced repeated brutality, including beatings and botched euthanasia attempts. Previous promises of reform by Coca-Cola proved empty, confirming systemic rather than isolated cruelty.
Across the Atlantic, Animal Justice Project (AJP) uncovered similar horrors at Lowfields Farm, a major UK dairy certified as “high welfare” and “organic.” Investigators documented relentless abuse: workers routinely beat cows shortly after birth, violently handled newborn calves, and subjected injured cows to electric shocks and severe neglect. A farm manager candidly admitted, “It's not a farm anymore; it's a manufacturing business. We are manufacturing and selling milk and cows,” highlighting the stark ethical contradiction behind claims of compassionate care.
These investigations reveal not isolated incidents but symptoms of a fundamentally cruel system—one where animals are commodities, routinely exploited even under labels promising higher welfare standards. To grasp why such abuses persist, we must examine the inherent cruelties embedded within dairy farming itself.
What About the Good Apples?
The cruelty documented by undercover investigations isn't merely incidental—it’s deeply rooted in standard industry practices. Even in its purportedly milder forms, dairy farming inherently commodifies and exploits animals for profit. This system raises profound ethical tensions, as the relentless drive to maximize milk production often conflicts directly with genuine animal wellbeing, placing economic interests above compassion and care.
At the heart of dairy farming lies the relentless exploitation of female cows:
Repeated artificial insemination: Female cows endure invasive procedures to sustain continuous milk production, described by animal ethicist Kathryn Gillespie as a disturbing “sexually violent commodification” of their reproductive systems.
Maternal separation: Calves are routinely separated from their mothers shortly after birth, causing profound psychological trauma to both. This separation is neither accidental nor incidental—it’s integral to maximize milk yields.
Systematic culling: Male calves, deemed economically useless by the industry, are typically slaughtered young for veal or beef, while female calves are condemned to repeat their mothers' cycles of exploitation.
These practices become morally indefensible when examined through the lens of modern animal ethics, which acknowledges that cows and calves are sentient beings—capable of experiencing pain, fear, and deep emotional suffering. Dairy farming presents a profound ethical contradiction: farmers often claim genuine care and affection for their animals, yet simultaneously subject them to repeated traumas and exploitation that inevitably culminate in slaughter. This troubling disconnect between professed care and actual treatment highlights a fundamental ethical conflict within the industry, calling into question the sincerity of such claims of compassion.
Even the Best Apples Come From A Rotten Tree
Thanks to increased media attention highlighting animal suffering on farms, consumers now desperately seek labels that reassure them their purchases align with their values. Many willingly pay premium prices for products labeled “humane,” “organic,” or “high welfare,” believing their extra spending directly supports improved animal well-being—and, as the industry regularly claims, results in higher-quality products. After all, happier and healthier cows produce better milk, right?
Yet, as revealed earlier through the Animal Justice Project’s disturbing investigation at Lowfields Farm, even certified farms can hide severe cruelty behind reassuring labels. This UK dairy, proudly bearing Red Tractor assurance, was exposed for horrific abuses toward cows and calves, shattering consumer trust. Unfortunately, Lowfields is not an isolated example. Just last year, Farm Forward uncovered similar deception at Alexandre Family Farm, a prominent certified-organic dairy in the United States. Their report, titled “Dairy Deception: Corruption and Consumer Fraud,” documented severe neglect: untreated wounds, sick and injured cows left to suffer, calves confined in horrific conditions, and visibly injured animals denied care. This exposé vividly illustrates how certifications often function primarily as marketing tools, offering a false sense of ethical consumption while systemic suffering persists unchecked. Such revelations challenge the integrity of labeling systems and underscore the need for deeper scrutiny beyond superficial assurances.
Shining a Light in the Orchard
If it wasn’t for organizations like ‘Farm Forward’, ‘Animal Recovery Mission’, ‘Animal Justice Project’, and others, these abuses would largely remain hidden from the public without the courageous work of undercover investigators. Animal advocacy groups conduct undercover operations at considerable personal and legal risk, especially in regions with “ag-gag” laws designed explicitly to criminalize the documentation of farming conditions.
Yet even when evidence of cruelty is documented, enforcement faces substantial hurdles. Many state cruelty statutes contain exemptions for “common agricultural practices,” broadly interpreted by prosecutors and courts, effectively shielding standard industry procedures from legal repercussions. Prosecutors often defer to industry “experts” who dismiss documented abuses as merely “clumsy” actions or the result of untrained personnel, rather than recognizing them as “willfully cruel.” Furthermore, limited avenues for enforcement and the lack of private rights of action severely restrict advocates' ability to hold factory farms accountable. The Humane Methods of Slaughter Act (HMSA), while ostensibly protecting animals, lacks effective enforcement due to a tiered system allowing facilities to remedy abuses without significant penalties.
Your Choice Matters
Despite the gloomy legal and enforcement landscape surrounding the dairy industry, consumers wield substantial power to effect change. Public awareness—driven by courageous undercover investigations and ongoing advocacy—shapes consumer choices, challenging entrenched industry practices from the ground up. As we confront these troubling realities, it becomes clear that cruelty in dairy farming isn't merely the fault of isolated “bad apples,” but a systemic issue deeply woven into the industry's fabric. Routine cruelty, deceptive labeling, and inadequate oversight combine to perpetuate exploitation and suffering.
The moral imperative is undeniable: If we truly care about animals, environmental sustainability, and ethical integrity, we must critically examine our role in supporting these systems. Rejecting dairy isn't just a dietary preference—it's an ethical stance against cruelty, exploitation, and deception.
It’s time to choose compassion over convenience. Let the inherent cruelty of dairy be reason enough to explore plant-based alternatives. By making kinder food choices, we refuse to support a system that prioritizes profit over animal well-being, human health, and the future of our planet.
Together, let's build a kinder future.
Please ditch dairy.
Sources & Further Reading
Farm Forward (2023). DAIRY DECEPTION: Corruption and Consumer Fraud at Alexandre Family Farm. Farm Forward.
https://www.farmforward.com/publications/dairy-deception-corruption-and-consumer-fraud/Taylor, Angus. Animal Ethics and the Dairy Industry: Exposing Ethical Contradictions. Animal Studies Journal.
https://www.researchgate.net/publication/364652356_Animals_and_Ethics_An_Overview_of_the_Philosophical_Debate_cover_image_onlyARM Investigations. Operation Fairlife Arizona.
https://animalrecoverymission.org/operations/factory-farm-division/operation-fairlife-arizona/Animal Justice Project. The Alarming Reality of Dairy Farming.
https://www.animaljusticeproject.com/campaigns/lowfieldsReview of Law and Social Justice. Do Animal Protection Laws Address Widespread Cruelty? Unique Challenges and Potential for Addressing Institutional Abuse to Farmed Animals. Review of Law and Social Justice.
https://gould.usc.edu/students/journals/rlsj/issues/assets/docs/volume32/winter2023/leahy.pdfFarm Forward. Exposing Ag-Gag: The Assault on Transparency and Animal Welfare.
https://www.farmforward.com/publications/exposing-ag-gag/
If this post has inspired you to rethink your relationship with dairy, we’re here to help you on your journey. Explore the resources below to learn more, find support, and discover delicious alternatives:
Discover Dairy-Free Products: Check out our list of plant-based milk, cheese, yogurt, and more! You’ll be surprised by the variety.
Sign Up for Vegan Boot Camp: Get all the guidance and support you need to transition to a compassionate lifestyle.
Follow Us on Social Media: Stay updated on the latest facts about the cruelty of dairy farming, get inspiration, and connect with a community motivated to make a difference. Instagram | Facebook | X | BlueSky
Join our Newsletter Waitlist: sign-up below